
In Scene Six, Law showed that no one, whether the guilty or the disciplined, can fulfil the standard by their own strength. Now the defence calls a witness that Sin and Satan hoped would never come near this case.
In this scene: The Bailiff · The Almighty Judge · The Advocate · Grace · Satan · Sin · Brother Self-Righteous · Sister Immoral
(The courtroom is back in session. Law’s testimony has left Brother Self-Righteous unusually quiet. He sits with his hands clasped, occasionally glancing towards Sister Immoral. She appears less afraid of her own record, but the question of how she can be declared righteous still weighs on her.)
(At the prosecution table, Satan reviews his notes. Sin paces impatiently behind him.)
BAILIFF: All rise! The Almighty Judge presiding. Court is now in session!
(The Judge enters and takes His seat.)
JUDGE: Be seated.
(Everyone sits.)
JUDGE: At the previous sitting, the court heard from Law. The standard has been established, and the limits of human achievement have been made clear. The defence may now call its next witness.
ADVOCATE: Thank you, Your Honour. The defence calls Grace.
(The courtroom stirs. Satan slowly raises his head. Sin stops pacing.)
SIN: Grace? He is calling Grace?
SATAN: I heard him.
SIN: I thought we had agreed not to let her anywhere near this case!
SATAN: And how exactly did you intend to stop her?
(Before Sin can answer, the side door opens.)
BAILIFF: Call Grace!
(GRACE enters. She is composed and dignified, carrying no files and wearing no expression of triumph. She looks neither at Satan with hostility nor at Sister Immoral with pity. She takes the oath and stands before the Judge.)
JUDGE: Grace, you have been called to explain your purpose and your relationship to the question before this court. Do you understand?
GRACE: I do, Your Honour.
ADVOCATE: Grace, please tell the court who you are.
GRACE: I am the undeserved favour of God towards those who cannot establish a claim upon Him through their own merit. I do not arrive because people have made themselves worthy of me. I come because God has chosen to give what they cannot earn.
SATAN: (rising) Objection!
JUDGE: On what grounds?
SATAN: The witness has described herself in terms that already favour the defence. I ask that she be required to explain how such favour can coexist with justice.
JUDGE: That is a proper question for cross-examination. The witness may continue.
ADVOCATE: Grace, does your presence mean that wrongdoing no longer matters?
GRACE: No.
ADVOCATE: Does it mean that the Law should be ignored?
GRACE: No.
ADVOCATE: Does it mean that a person can deliberately continue in wrongdoing and appeal to you as though I were an accomplice to their rebellion?
GRACE: No. I do not teach people to love the very thing that destroys them. I bring them to the One who saves them from it.
ADVOCATE: Then explain why you are here.
(Grace looks towards Sister Immoral.)
GRACE: Because people often imagine that they must first make themselves worthy before they can come to God. They try to repair every weakness, hide every failure, and produce a record that will persuade Him to receive them. But if acceptance must be earned before it can be received, then it is no longer a gift.
SATAN: Yet the court has already established that the accused is guilty.
GRACE: And I have not come to dispute that.
SATAN: She has repeatedly done wrong.
GRACE: I know.
SATAN: She has broken promises.
GRACE: I know.
SATAN: She has hurt people and failed to live up to what she knew was right.
GRACE: I know.
SATAN: Then what exactly do you have to offer her?
(Grace turns towards him.)
GRACE: What she could never purchase for herself.
SATAN: That is a beautiful phrase, but this is a court of law, not a poetry recital. What do you actually offer?
GRACE: I offer no alternative to the work of the Advocate. I point to it. The gift I announce rests on what He has accomplished, not on the strength of the person receiving it.
SATAN: So you admit that you depend on Him?
GRACE: Of course. Grace does not present itself as a substitute for Christ. It reveals the goodness of what God has provided through Him.
(The Advocate nods slightly.)
SATAN: Let us examine your philosophy, then. Suppose Sister Immoral is declared righteous today. Suppose she leaves this courtroom and returns tomorrow to the very conduct that brought her here. Will you still defend her?
GRACE: I will not call her wrongdoing acceptable.
SATAN: That is not what I asked.
GRACE: And I will not confuse her struggle with a licence to abandon the life she has been given. If she falls, she must return to the Advocate, confess the truth, receive correction, and continue in the path of transformation. I am not permission to remain a prisoner. I am the gift that opens the door to freedom.
SATAN: You make it sound as though there is always another chance.
GRACE: You say that as though the number of chances you believe a person deserves is the measure of God’s goodness.
SATAN: Are you suggesting there should be no consequences?
GRACE: No. Some consequences remain. Some harms require restitution. Some relationships need rebuilding. Some patterns require discipline, support, and time to overcome. Forgiveness does not make these responsibilities disappear.
SATAN: Then you are not as generous as people claim.
GRACE: Generosity is not the same as pretending that nothing matters.
(A murmur of approval comes from the gallery.)
SATAN: Silence in the courtroom! (He catches himself and looks towards the Judge.) I beg your pardon, Your Honour.
JUDGE: You may continue, Prosecutor. But remember that you do not preside here.
(Satan returns to the witness stand.)
SATAN: Grace, I have another question. If righteousness can be received as a gift, what becomes of those who have worked hard to obey? What becomes of the person who has spent years resisting temptation, serving others, and sacrificing personal comfort to do what is right? Is all of that worth nothing?
(Brother Self-Righteous leans forward.)
GRACE: Goodness is not worthless because it cannot purchase justification. Obedience matters. Love matters. Service matters. But their value is not diminished by acknowledging that they are not the price of God’s acceptance.
SATAN: So the obedient and the disobedient receive the same reward?
GRACE: That is not what I said. Their lives, choices, and consequences are not identical. But neither can the obedient person use their record to boast before God as though grace were unnecessary.
(She looks towards Brother Self-Righteous.)
GRACE: You may have done many good things, Brother. I do not need to deny that. But goodness was never meant to become a wall behind which you hide from your own need.
(Brother Self-Righteous looks away.)
GRACE: The person who knows they are sick may seek a physician. But the person who insists they are perfectly healthy because someone else is more seriously ill may never seek the treatment they need.
SATAN: Another illustration!
GRACE: Would you prefer the truth without one?
SATAN: I would prefer an answer that does not make the Law look unnecessary.
GRACE: Then let us be clear. The Law reveals what is right. The Advocate has accomplished what the guilty could not accomplish for themselves. I announce the gift that is received through faith, and I lead those who receive it into a new life. None of these truths requires the others to be denied.
SATAN: You claim to lead people into a new life. Yet people who speak of you still fail.
GRACE: Yes, they do.
SATAN: They still struggle with pride, anger, lust, envy, dishonesty, and selfishness.
GRACE: Yes.
SATAN: Then where is the evidence of your power?
GRACE: You are asking me to prove the reality of grace by showing you a person who has already completed the entire journey of transformation. But transformation is a work that unfolds in a person’s life. Its beginning is not the same as its completion.
SATAN: So you ask us to accept the accused before she has finished changing?
GRACE: I ask you to understand the order of things. She is not justified because she has completed her transformation. She is justified through faith in the Advocate. And because she has received grace, she is called to grow in the life He gives.
ADVOCATE: (rising) Your Honour, I would like the court to note the witness’s final distinction. Grace does not make transformation unnecessary. It makes transformation possible without requiring the sinner to earn the right to begin.
JUDGE: Noted.
(Satan returns to his table and begins arranging his papers with unusual force.)
SATAN: Your Honour, I have no further questions for this witness at present.
JUDGE: Defence?
ADVOCATE: One final question.
(The Advocate approaches Grace.)
ADVOCATE: Grace, if you do not erase the truth about the accused’s past, and you do not declare her wrongdoing acceptable, what is the foundation of the hope you offer her?
GRACE: The character of God and the work of the Advocate. I do not ask the guilty to pretend that they have never sinned. I invite them to trust the One who has dealt with their sin and offers them a new life.
ADVOCATE: And can a person purchase that gift?
GRACE: No.
ADVOCATE: Can a person boast that they deserve it more than someone else?
GRACE: No.
ADVOCATE: How, then, is it received?
GRACE: Through faith.
(The Advocate returns to his seat.)
JUDGE: The testimony is noted. Grace may step down.
(Grace steps away from the witness stand, but before she leaves the courtroom, Sister Immoral rises.)
SISTER IMMORAL: Your Honour, may I ask the witness one question?
JUDGE: You may.
(Sister Immoral turns towards Grace.)
SISTER IMMORAL: I understand that I cannot earn what you offer. But sometimes I am afraid that my repeated failures prove I never truly changed. How do I know that I am not simply deceiving myself?
(Grace looks at her with compassion.)
GRACE: Sister, a person who receives a new life does not instantly become a person who has never struggled. The question is not whether you will ever need correction again. The question is whether you will trust the Advocate enough to bring your failures into the light, receive His correction, and keep walking with Him.
SISTER IMMORAL: So I do not have to pretend I am stronger than I am?
GRACE: No. You must be honest about your weakness. But do not make an identity out of the very thing from which you are being delivered.
(Sister Immoral nods, taking in the words.)
GRACE: And remember this: the purpose of grace is not merely to bring you out of condemnation. It is also to teach you to live in the freedom you have received.
(Grace leaves the courtroom.)
(For a long moment, no one speaks.)
BROTHER SELF-RIGHTEOUS: (quietly, almost to himself) Then all these years, I may have been doing good things for the wrong reason.
SIN: What did you say?
BROTHER SELF-RIGHTEOUS: Nothing.
SIN: I heard you.
BROTHER SELF-RIGHTEOUS: Then you heard correctly.
(Sin stares at him, unsettled.)
(Satan slowly rises.)
SATAN: Your Honour, the witness has spoken eloquently. But eloquence is not proof. Grace has explained the gift, but she has not established the basis on which the accused can receive it. If the Law’s demands remain, and if grace cannot simply ignore them, then the defence must show exactly how the demands have been met.
(He turns towards the Advocate.)
SATAN: You have promised us an answer concerning righteousness. I suggest we hear it now.
ADVOCATE: I agree.
(The Advocate rises and faces the Judge.)
ADVOCATE: Your Honour, the defence is ready to address the question at the heart of this case: how the righteousness I have fulfilled can be counted in favour of those who trust Me.
JUDGE: The court will hear the argument at the next sitting.
BAILIFF: All rise!
(Everyone stands. The Judge exits.)
(Brother Self-Righteous remains seated for a moment after everyone else has risen, deep in thought. Sister Immoral looks towards the Advocate, and this time she does not ask whether He will stay. She simply waits for Him.)
(Across the room, Satan closes his file.)
SATAN: (quietly to Sin) We have dealt with guilt. We have dealt with grace. Now let us see whether he can establish righteousness.
SIN: And if he can?
(Satan does not answer immediately.)
SATAN: Then we may have a problem.
(Lights fade.)
— End of Scene Seven —
Your turn: Grace tells Sister Immoral, “Do not make an identity out of the very thing from which you are being delivered.” What does that mean to you? Share your thoughts in the comments.
Coming next: Scene Eight — The Righteousness of Another. The guilt and the standard have both been addressed. Now the Advocate answers Satan’s hardest question: how can His righteousness count for someone else?
The Righteous One: A Christian Allegorical Drama by Restpirant Jerome



